In Hong Kong, it's almost unusual to hear of a family without a "domestic helper," or "ya-ya"s (Tagalog for 'nanny'); even my ya-ya who worked for my family has a ya-ya for her son. But even though having a ya-ya in Hong Kong is the norm, my family wouldn't employ a help if we didn't really need it, and, truthfully, we do; both my parents leave at 8 in the morning and often don't return until 11 at night and they go on business trips at least twice a month. No one is left to take care of the house or the dog, especially since my sister and I are away at school.
So naturally, I find issue with Ehrenreich's claim that, "real work... tends to vanish." I couldn't even imagine how offended my parents would be if I ever told them that they weren't doing "real" work!
I also cannot bring myself to sympathize with Ehrenreich, especially when she makes very unfair, accusatory statements like, "a servant economy breeds callousness and solipsism."
So I guess my question is, what are working women supposed to do? What am I supposed to do, if, as the daughter, I should be "filling in" for my mother, but am, instead, away at school---which my mother must work to pay for?!! Also--and maybe I'm missing the entire point of Ehrenreich's article and missing the big picture--but what is so wrong with outsourcing domestic work, when it's not a matter of relegating dirty work, but a matter of not having enough hours in the day? Also, when can the pressure on women to do everything--job, take care of and raise baby, cook, clean--be lifted? It's no wonder why more and more women are hiring other women to do housework.
No comments:
Post a Comment